ohhh tyre fitters...
Tyre manufacturers as well as Porsche, would not dare mention that N rated tyres have to be fitted otherwise an insurance company would not pay out.. If they did, the fines from the EU as part of the competition and block exemption rules would bring them to their knees.
However, tyre company reps, like the bridgestone rep that once visited me, tend to have a big mouth and a vested interest in selling their brand and will say things like "Insurance companies will not pay out if N rated tyres are not fitted". Fortunately, as soon as I mentioned block exemption to the bridgestone rep, he became a bit coy, embarrassed and back tracked.
N rating is awarded by Porsche, usually as a complicated deal between tyre manufacturers and the Porsche factory, where tyres are supplied free of charge to the manufacturer, in exchange for the award of that tyre product being awarded "N" rating.
Under current EU law, a vehicle manufacturer or other agent can not specify what parts are used to maintain a car, once the car is sold, in any shape and form, which includes insurance companies taking any notice of what parts are made, or approved, by the manufacturer.
The only provision is that the parts have to be of equal quality as the original component and conform to local regulations, such as the "road traffic act" or "construction and use" in the UK, or TUV approval laws in Germany.
This becomes a bit of a sticky issue... If you fit a really dodgy fake part from China.. then technically your insurance company can void a claim, or a main dealer can void your warranty. More than anything, this is the case that Aviva (for example) could argue that the part was sub standard, and the manufacturer would not care about their name being slated, or your problem.. However, if you use parts from a large manufacturer, such as Continental (Barum) then if Porsche or Aviva tried to say it was substandard, then Continental would probably earn more that year from the court case, than they would out of tyres.
Not only this, but it would also ruin a beautiful relationship between Porsche and Continental.
The only time a UK main dealer get funny, is once you are out of the manufacturers warranty, and into the "extended warranty" where the manufacturer is no longer underwriting the warranty, and a investment company is, in which case, you are down to a contract between yourself and the investment company, that you will only use genuine Porsche parts, otherwise they can void your contract... Block exemption only effects manufacturers and the interests of road worthynes, however a contract between you and "XYZ Investments on Behalf of Porsche Cars GB" (Note, not "Porsche") is a civil matter between you and the XYZ... So they can, and have, invalidated a claim for a blown up engine, on the basis of your upgrading your radio to a Alpine unit, or the installation of a Parrot hands free kit.
Insurance companies are different though, their contract with you, has to be a standard contract of insurance, valid europe wide and within the template set down by the EU, which means they can't pull any "Has to be manufacturer approved" bull...
Which, also opens up a can of worms, where technically, if you fit a good quality wastegate to your car as an alternative to a genuine part, rather than for its performance benefits, they can not penalise you... Which I would not advocate, but its an interesting point of law.
In short, an insurance company insisting on N rated tyre, would be like them being involved in a conspiracy to assist in a monopoly by the manufacturer of the car, which was why the EU block exemption rules were drafted.
Tyre fitters, a very special breed, tend to believe everything the tyre reps say..
I am sure you will like the Barums, I think they are awesome all weather tyres and even held up really well on trackdays.
_________________ Clean it, wax it, love it, ENJOY it... then fix it
Jon Mitchell Independent Porsche Specialists Technical Advisors to TIPEC http://www.jmgporsche.co.uk https://twitter.com/JMG_PORSCHE http://www.facebook.com/jmgporsche
|