Have you just answered your own issues?
swb landy wrote:
I have a spare shaft, I bought it because there is a bit of play in the shaft when I grab it and give it a shake with the car on its wheels. . .
If there's play when you shake the shaft then there's play in the CV's!!
swb landy wrote:
front wheel drive car joints only knock when the wheel is turning the car round a corner, unless I have a very special 944 with rear wheel steering then my wheels should be in a straight line.
What do you think happens to the CV's when the car is listing to one side in a bend? The CV's do their work on the rear of a 944 the same as they would on the front of a Fiesta turning a corner. The rear wheel v's gearbox angle changes in the horizontal axis versus vertical on a FWD car
My money is on at least one CV needed. There's four needed to do the job right. May as well check the wheel bearings whilst the shafts are off.